Forum Discussion

MSGlow's avatar
MSGlow
On our wavelength
10 days ago

Bang & Olufsen Beocom 2 and 6000 not working

Following our landline switch over to the Virgin fibre digital service last Thursday our B&O cordless phones can make outgoing calls but prevent any incoming calls. They do not ring and any incoming call fails without being diverted to voicemail. The Virgin engineer who did the switchover did a good job cabling to the upstairs router but was at a loss to explain the fault. Another engineer who subsequently attended was also unable to help. Because of age and health concerns we are classed as ‘vulnerable’ yet Virgin have been singularly unhelpful to date; they have left us with no cordless phones and never highlighted this risk prior to the switchover.

Can anyone help with getting our phones working?

46 Replies

  • MSGlow's avatar
    MSGlow
    On our wavelength

    Oh dear i never realised and the Virgin operatives I've had dealings with just shrug their shoulders. With no prior warning the result is we are left with no working cordless phones. This has been a shabby service from Virgin.

    • goslow's avatar
      goslow
      Alessandro Volta

      At one point in the past, there were quite a few topics about this on the forum (sadly now gone into the forum dustbin/archive) so there are no useful topics to refer back to.

      The Beocom phones are now 'vintage' and, based on what I can recall from the past discussions, I think they were designed specifically for the line conditions and signalling that would be found on a traditional BT exchange line from that time period. I assume that the electronic device mentioned above takes the incoming phone signal from the VM hub and converts it to a format that the Beocom phones can recognise.

      I would suggest that you should make contact with the firm mentioned to investigate prices for the device mentioned if you want to continue using the Beocom phones.

      Alternatively you could look at a modern cordless system to use with the connection from the VM hub.

      In the meantime (if you need something to use on a temorary basis) you could pick up a cheap corded handset until you can sort out some sort of cordless replacement or a fix for the Beocoms. You can get a cheap corded phone for around £10 or maybe a friend, family member or neighbour can lend you a phone while you work out a permanent resolution.

      VM has just been fined £23.8 million by OFCOM for failing to ensure the switchover was carried out appropriately for vulnerable users.

      Do you have access to mobile phones? If not, VM should offer to provide you with a suitable (corded) backup phone which also has the ability to make calls in a power cut.

      A VM person should reply to our topic (usually within a few days, or sooner if someone flags it). They won't be able to get your Beocom phones working but they should not have left you in a position with no working cordless phones and no explanation of other possible options.

      • MSGlow's avatar
        MSGlow
        On our wavelength

        Many thanks for your very useful advice. I have plugged in a wired phone which works so those who only have our landline number will be able to ring it. We also have mobiles but I was just concerned that not all that need to get in contact had their numbers. It has been a somewhat frustrating interaction with VM - its the lack of communication and advice/knowledge that has be so annoying. Thanks again.

  • Client62's avatar
    Client62
    Alessandro Volta

    My concern with the B&O phones is their age, buy now the rechargeable batteries must have needed replacing several times, I did not see the type used to see if they remain available.

    The Beocom 2 (quite a piece of art) and the Beocom 6000 are both described at DECT phones.

    Could the B&O DECT handsets be re-paired to say a current BT DECT cordless base unit ? 

    https://beoworld.org/beocom-2/

    https://beocentral.com/beocom6000

    • MSGlow's avatar
      MSGlow
      On our wavelength

      Thanks for your input. I don’t know the answer to the repairing idea. We’ve had the phones since about 2009 and never needed to change the rechargeable batteries - they seem to be as good as new. They are, or were, excellent reliable phones. As with all B&O kit they were expensive and beautifully designed; the Beocom 2 in particular not just a phone but a talking point!

      • Client62's avatar
        Client62
        Alessandro Volta

        Indeed, in the past owners of BeoCom Phones have come on this forum and done nothing past posting critical comments. They have not investigated if a 3 wire UK ringing circuit was needed as that is a key difference between the VM Hub Tel 1 socket and a VM/BT wall socket as is provided for an VM/BT exchange driven analogue phone line.

        Usually a Hub/Router with an internal telephone adaptor like VM and EE provide does give enough ringing voltage, especially as the line to the exchange has gone and the telephone is now connected over a cable of say 2 metres where previously it could have been a public telephone line of over 2 miles.

        We know the VM supplied RJ11 to BT Socket adaptor does not have an internal ring capacitor, the earlier the telephone is, the more likely the ring capacitor is needed.

        I do not suppose in your rummage box you have an ADSL Splitter ? Remember the type they plugged into a phone socket so a telephone phone and ASDL Router could be used.

        If you do try : 

        VM Hub Tel 1 >> VM RJ11 to BT Socket Adaptor >> ADSL Splitter >> BeoCom connected to the telephone socket of the ADSL splitter.

        Why this ... ADSL Telephone Splitter contain a Ring Capacitor and I do not recall seeing many complaints about phones not working via the splitters supplied by main ISPs.



    • MSGlow's avatar
      MSGlow
      On our wavelength

      Thanks I'll give a peruse...

  • MSGlow's avatar
    MSGlow
    On our wavelength

    It's all rather complicated to someone not digi (or indeed analogue) comms savvy. But thanks to all for trying to help. I think I'll get in touch with the vintage telephony guys who sorted SDM123 Beocom issues out... I'm sure there must be more frustrated people like me out there who want to keep their nicely designed Beocoms going. So surely there is a market for some electronics guys to corner...

  • Client62's avatar
    Client62
    Alessandro Volta

    There is no market to corner.

    We have been with VM since 2017 and I suspect this is barely 10th time similar issues with B&O phones have come on this forum.  It is a memorable topic because is it so rare.

      • Client62's avatar
        Client62
        Alessandro Volta

        No but if I did I've have more tools on hand to dig deeper, we have a Cisco SPA112 ATA where the Ringing Voltage & Frequency and Ringing signal shape & cadence are all controllable and can be set to be identical to a BT exchange. 

        A VM Hub lacks these options for the telephone ports.

        The B&O kit I had was not a telephone :  https://beoworld.org/beogram-3400/ 

  • MSGlow's avatar
    MSGlow
    On our wavelength

    Thanks @goslow, your replies on this subject have been very informative. I had presumed that VM would not be able to fix the core issue, but I have yet to receive a definitive answer, yeah or nay, from the horses mouth as it were.

    • goslow's avatar
      goslow
      Alessandro Volta

      You will get no useful answer from VM. They will simply tell you that they don't support third party equipment and particularly so if it is 'vintage' equipment.

      You are more likely to get a useful answer from the 'vintage telephony' company linked earlier in the topic. They should be able to explain why the B&O phones do not work on the VM hub and what cost their adapter device is and what it is the adapter actually does. (I suspect it is something along the lines of modifying the incoming signal/voltage from the VM hub into a format that the B&O phones can recognise).

      If you speak to them and you get any useful feedback, post up the info on here as it may help someone else in the future with the same problem

  • MSGlow's avatar
    MSGlow
    On our wavelength

    Will do, they are away until next week.

  • MSGlow's avatar
    MSGlow
    On our wavelength

    As suggested by #goslow I contacted the vintage telephony guy (Chris) as used by SDM123. An interesting conversation - the upshot was that the ‘work round’ for SDM123 was simply to install a resistor between the router and the Beoline base station. A more elegant solution was not possible as the circuitry in the Beoline 2 handset was rather opaque and no circuit diagrams have been publicly published by B&O. SDM123’s issue  was diagnosed as being due to an inappropriate current level being supplied from the router which triggers the pick-up circuitry but not the ring functionality. The work round was to stick a resistor in a box that is connected in series betwixt router and base station. Chris did not regard this as a solution as it leaves the inappropriate circuitry in the phone/base station intact. When they return to their shop next week I will be able to send the Beoline base station, the Beocom 2 and the two Beocom 6000’s to see if he can do the same trick he did for SDM123. Although he couldn’t guarantee success. He also said that the B&O phones were the only make he’d come across that have this issue.

    • goslow's avatar
      goslow
      Alessandro Volta

      Very interesting. That sounds like you have made some useful progress. Seems like he is saying the current being drawn when a call comes in makes the phone think it has been picked up/answered so there is no ringing when a call comes in. Hopefully he can replicate the same fix for you.

    • Client62's avatar
      Client62
      Alessandro Volta

      Add what value of Resistor ? 

      Is the Resistor in series with the phone or is the Resistor across the telephone line ? 

      • goslow's avatar
        goslow
        Alessandro Volta

        I imagine that Mr Vintage Telephony might regard that knowledge as top secret info! 😁

        Maybe he needs to tweak the value to get reliable results with particular equipment which is why he asks customers to send in the kit they want to use.

  • MSGlow's avatar
    MSGlow
    On our wavelength

    Just a little update. I spoke to the our excellent B&O engineer that has installed other B&O non phone kit over the years and he told me that in the last couple of years he's had quite a few queries on the VM/Beocom issue. He has spoken to the B&O mother ship and they aren't interested. He hasn't found a reliable solution despite trying with a number of customers - sometimes his efforts  which are basically a reinstall work sometimes not. Doing a little more AI aided research the following has been suggested using an ATA ( a Grandstream HT801). I think #Client62 uses a similar device but not with Beocoms? Dr AI suggests that with my current setup it should work with no tweaking but I am a naturally sceptical cove. 

                          FIRST FLOOR (Office)
            ┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
            │          Virgin Media Hub               │
            │          TEL1 Port (Analogue Out)       │
            └───────────────┬─────────────────────────┘
                            │ RJ11 Cable
                            ▼
                     ┌────────────────────┐
                     │   HT801 ATA        │
                     │  (Line Stabiliser) │
                     │  FXS / PHONE Port  │
                     └──────────┬─────────┘
                                │ RJ11 Cable
                                ▼
                 Office Virgin Wall Socket (RJ45 Type)
                                │
                                ▼
                     Internal Cat5e Cable Run
            (Already installed – carries phone line perfectly)
                                │
                                ▼
               Living Room Virgin Wall Socket (RJ45 Type)
                                │
                                ▼
                     BT → RJ11 Adapter (Your Existing/New)
                                │
                                ▼
                 ┌─────────────────────────────────┐
                 │   B&O Base Station (Beocom)     │
                 │   BT Plug → Adapter → Wall      │
                 └─────────────────────────────────┘

    The advice also suggested that if such tweaks were needed they would be along the lines of configuring the ATA as indicated below.

    'Optional' ATA configuration setting tweaks for the ATA FXS Port:

    Impedance: 370+620||310nF

    Caller ID Scheme: ETSI-FSK

    Ring Frequency: 25 Hz

    Ring Tone: UK Standard

    Ring Voltage: Set to HIGH (HT801 supports up to 90V)

    Loop Current: Set to 18–20 mA

    Polarity Reversal: NO (Virgin does not use it)

    Current Disconnect Threshold: 900 ms

    The AI advice is that these settings make the HT801 emulate a proper BT exchange line, which B&O base stations expect.

    Does this sound plausible?

    It also begs the question  - Can the VM Hub FXS Port not be so configured?

     

    • goslow's avatar
      goslow
      Alessandro Volta

      I think Client62 uses an independent VOIP provider for telephony. The device you have linked allows a user to connect analogue telephones to a VOIP service.

      In VM's offering, the conversion has already taken place in the VM hub which allows customers to connect a domestic telephone to the hub. In the VM product though, there are no means to change any of the telephony settings as those are all controlled by VM.

      My recollection of past topics aligns with your B&O engineer's account. Some managed to get things working but not in a reliable way. After initial success the phones failed at some later point.

      This topic was listed on the Beoworld website

      https://forum.beoworld.org/forums/topic/beocom-technical-advice-required/#post-34370

      with one post claiming success and describing a procedure but only try it if you have plenty of time on your hands as others in the topic could not reproduce the same success so use at your own risk!

      • Adduxi's avatar
        Adduxi
        Very Insightful Person

        IMHO VM do not provide a "proper" VOIP solution.  A VOIP supplier will allow you to configure your VOIP setup as you see fit. 

        I had a Grandstream ATA using Sipgate, and it just connected to the existing BT socket and extension.  Both phones worked as expected. I kept this until I realised no one was actually using my landline number, so it's now gone.

        You cannot do this with VM as they don't allow the end user to configure anything.  It's just a take it or leave it, plug and play, telephone service.

    • Client62's avatar
      Client62
      Alessandro Volta

      There are Zero user settings in a VM Hub for the telephone ports, it is 100% locked down.

      We have used the Cisco SPA 112 since 2017, it is an alternative to the Grandstream HT801,
      Cisco ATA 191 is the current model.  The key appears to be access to configure the line behaviours,  the choice of Cisco or Grandstream not being important.

      Here from the Cisco SPA 112 are some of the Regional settings I made to emulate a BT line,
      they are mostly similar to those mentioned earlier.