Forum Discussion

Cardiffman282's avatar
Cardiffman282
Community elder
23 days ago

VM has a "Fake Review Policy"

Which got me wondering a few things:

  1. Is it a review policy that is in fact fake?
  2. Is it a fake review policy that is in fact true? 
  3. Lastly... just...why?

It is undated but seems fairly new 

https://www.virginmedia.com/dynamo/legal/fake-review-policy

It initially flashes a 404 error on loading regardless of the browser used which sort of doubles down on the fakery side of things. 

In addition the main email address given for reporting "inappropriate" reviews (undefined) is actually an O2 domain but we are assured that's it's good for VM reviews too. 

Also I initially assumed that it was VM threatening terrible Hell-in-a-handcart sanctions against customers posting bad reviews.

 However it seems VM sometimes rewards reviewers with hard cash and "freebies" according to the policy. I have seen this sort of thing on Trustpilot with a number of companies and there is a "verified" tag used for these. However of the thousands of reviews of VM on Trustpilot I could only find 12 verified reviews using the filter. Of these 12 reviews just one is positive. 

Has anyone on here been incentivised to review VM? Was it conditional on providing a nice one? What did you get in return? Where is the review? 

8 Replies

  • jpeg1's avatar
    jpeg1
    Alessandro Volta

    Posting a positive review on Trustpilot would be like Canute holding back the tide. 

    • pedlar1's avatar
      pedlar1
      Up to speed

      Need to check if reviewer is verified. Reviews ( verified) do help consumers. Which magazine is also very helpful.

      • Cardiffman282's avatar
        Cardiffman282
        Community elder

        Yeah I've always had a soft spot for Which? magazine. However it really pushes affiliate commission sales and price comparison commission sales on its website and feels a bit soiled and compromised because of it. 

  • goslow's avatar
    goslow
    Alessandro Volta

    A piece of classic VM 'confusion'! I give VM 5 stars for confusion!

      • Micha1978's avatar
        Micha1978
        Tuning in

        "Of these 12 reviews just one is positive."

        Possibly even the offer of cash or freebies isn’t enough to bribe many people to give VM a positive review!

        Also ‘Fake Review Policy’; is this a policy regarding ‘fake’ reviews or a ‘fake (non-existent) policy’ regarding reviews?

        Enquiring minds would like to know....