Forum Discussion

jg666's avatar
jg666
On our wavelength
2 years ago

BBC 3 Top Gear - failed recordings/Audio Description On

Yes I know I can turn Audio Description off during playback but it’s annoying that it is recording with this defaulting to On. Is there something I can do to stop this?

 

[MOD EDIT: Subject title changed for clarity]

13 Replies

  • jg666's avatar
    jg666
    On our wavelength

    And now the first episode I recorded tonight (Friday 7pm BBC3) won’t play. I go into the recording as usual and it says it has recorded 1h 3m but it behaves as if it has reached the end of the recording straight away. This is the 2nd time I’ve had this happen on a BBC3 Top Gear recording. 

     

    • Gareth_L's avatar
      Gareth_L
      Icon for Forum Team rankForum Team

      Hello jg666.

      Thank you for your post.

      Sorry to hear about Top Gear having Audio Description set as default when you play back a recording.

      Also sorry as well to hear the latest recording skips to the end.

      Can we please ask if what set top box you have?

      Gareth_L

  • I have a V6 box. I am currently doing tests on both of my boxes to see if the same thing happens on both for the same episode. I will report back if it does.

     

  • jg666's avatar
    jg666
    On our wavelength

    It has just done it again. I suspected it was the Friday 7pm episode that kept failing and indeed it is.

    I set it to record manually on one box and series link on the other box and they both have the same issue. They report that it has recorded one hour and three minutes and you try to play it and immediately it asks if you want to delete or keep the recording.

     

  • jg666's avatar
    jg666
    On our wavelength

    @gareth_l  is there any way I can change the title to be failed recordings rather than audio description? The issue now is the failed Friday episodes.

     

  • japitts's avatar
    japitts
    Very Insightful Person

    The reason for failed recordings on a TiVo/V6 can usually be identified via the recording hiccups folder.

    • jg666's avatar
      jg666
      On our wavelength

      There’s nothing listed there because the system thinks the recordings have succeeded in full. They just won’t play back.

       

  • japitts's avatar
    japitts
    Very Insightful Person

    Does the recording show a file size? I'm away from my V6 at present but from memory the "info" button pressed from the play-now screen should let you then scroll down to the file info.

    And to avoid doubt, are you definitely selecting "play from beginning"? Are you able to view it via TV Control?

    • jg666's avatar
      jg666
      On our wavelength

      In the info it says less than 1% (2.73GB)

      Yes I’m pressing play at the beginning of the recording.

      For these Top Gear recordings it says restrictions don’t allow streaming and they can only be played back via the box.

      I’ve had another play around with it because you press play and it displays something for a fraction of a second but then gives the delete message. So I pressed play and very quickly pressed pause. It is starting at the very end of the recording for some reason. It must be doing this for this 7pm recording every time. So once I’d paused I was able to rewind it all the way back to the beginning and then play it 🙂

      So there’s something wrong with this particular recording every time on both boxes, it’s starting playback right at the end and you have to be exrtemely quick with the pause button to be able to rewind!

       

  • jg666's avatar
    jg666
    On our wavelength

    For anyone else interested in testing etc there’s another instance of the 7pm Friday episode on the 26th April.

    I’m wondering if it’s because it is on for 58 minutes and then there’s a 2 minute catch-up program and then another episode of Top Gear at 8pm. For this reason I’m recording both episodes on one box and just the 7pm episode on the other box…. I suspect it will only happen when I record both.

    I have my recordings set to start 1 minute earlier and stop 4 minutes longer.

     

    • Gareth_L's avatar
      Gareth_L
      Icon for Forum Team rankForum Team

      Hello again jg666,

      Sorry for the delay in getting back to you.

      Can I please ask you to let me know how the tests go.

      Gareth_L

  • jg666's avatar
    jg666
    On our wavelength

    Test completed tonight.

    On one box I just recorded the 7pm Top Gear and that had the same fault on playback.

    On the other box I recorded both the 7pm and the 8pm episodes and that also had the same fault on playback.

    So my conclusion is that the 7pm recording is always faulty on playback, I suspect it’s something to do with the 2 minute program in the schedule straight after it.

     

    • John_GS's avatar
      John_GS
      Icon for Forum Team rankForum Team

      Hi jg666 

      Can you start the recordings earlier to see if that also throws up the issue? Say 5 mins earlier to see if it throws up the same result?