Forum Discussion

Buffer6's avatar
Buffer6
Alessandro Volta
11 months ago

New Forum..theme and design comments

What  do you think

Now we've lost a lot of facilities that used to be in previous Themes

Post editing facility, gone

Signatures, gone

Users on line, gone

Page thread view count, gone

Page numbering, gone

Video thumbs need cookie acceptance printed over the top of the thumb now

Text messages showing in one column about one third of width of page on my screen 

Ability to view newest posts first in a long thread or to go to the latest post quickly, gone

So  far this is what I've noticed . Is this an improvement or not?

                                                        Buffer6

226 Replies

  • On the specific point of sorting threads switching to "linear" sorting in preferences is working for me. 

    • MrHalfAsleep's avatar
      MrHalfAsleep
      Community elder

      More thoughts, musings etc.:

      [TL;DR/expansion:] Where is this going? Might as well switch the internet off; Make representations to your MP.

      [reply:] I did that too.  Links do work (albeit not properly), but if you try to reply to stuff, you get a pop-up telling you to remove the bad HTML and that your reply hasn't been published.  The post is persistent in the sense that it isn't deleted.  This is the only time you can edit posts/replies. 

      [expansion:] Deleting the links is counter productive and makes replies inaccurate whilst removing a basic tenet of the internet itself.  If this carries on, I no longer see the point of the forum as a whole.  It is now 04:09 in the morning, and I'm faffing about on here creating yet more irrelevant content.  

      [question:] Should we be able to post links or not?

      [Aside/further expansion/bigger picture:] I'm now having conversations with people suggesting that it now has become an either/or scenario:  If we're going to have electric cars, should we get rid of data centres and the internet?  Zero sum game.

  • goslow's avatar
    goslow
    Alessandro Volta

    The forum was switched over quickly but the current offering still seems to be very much a 'work in progress'.

    Rather than it being a user/discussion forum any more it seems to be heading off in more of a simple helpdesk/ticketing system (with a corresponding reduction in controls available to users). The new arrangement seems to be optimised for mobile devices and on the basis of completing the simple task of a customer logging an issue with VM and getting a reply.

    That said, IMO the present setup is an improvement on the previous version which tried to replicate features of the original forum but failed to do so very well.

    Not-working things I have noticed for me so far are:

    * No notifications are working (neither push notifications when logged in or email notifications since the switchover)

    * Automatic following of a topic (after making a reply) doesn't work. It looks as if it is doing that after posting but when moving away from the page and returning the 'follow' has not been applied. Manually ticking the follow button is required.

    * Not possible to post working hyperlinks (blocked by the new system). Only possible to post the text of a link. May be part of anti-spam measures gone-wrong. Also seems to be trying to so some sort of fancy self-title operating when using the insert hyperlink function.

    * Many controls from the 'preferences' page of the user profile have gone.

    * No access to past images under user profile, as far as I can see, and previously stored images seem to have gone (although I may have not yet discovered method for access if they do still exist)

    * Edit function still no longer available (which is a big limitation IMO). Would have thought this could/should be made available to established users on a permissions-based approach either by request or by forum 'rank' after maintaining an established posting history

    Current set of features available may reflect a change in function of what VM wants the forum to do IMHO.

    • Nerjagirl's avatar
      Nerjagirl
      Joining in

      I have just joined this Forum, and apart from being able to reply, have no way of posting a comment.  Please can someone help me?

      Virgin seem to make it as hard as humanly possible to contact them

      Kind Regards

       

    • japitts's avatar
      japitts
      Very Insightful Person

      Editing was removed from user profiles a month or so back on the "old" forum - only VIP & staff profiles have it currently.

      Edited to check that these permissions have been carried over, and they have.

      • goslow's avatar
        goslow
        Alessandro Volta

        Yes, I was aware it had gone but I was rather hoping it was going to come back again!!