Hey @GC88,
Welcome to the community and thanks for taking the time to post your issue on the forums.
I'm sorry for the issues that you're having with your new online account, the former account would still have the email linked to it, if you're using the same email address.
I would be happy to take a further look into this for you but would need to confirm a few details over via private message, please look out for my message and we can get started.
Regards,
Steven_L